Real Estate Published

Low Appraisal on a Texas Home Sale: A Seller Guide

TREC 40-11 lets a financed buyer terminate if Property Approval fails; TREC 49-1 can waive or limit that. What East Texas sellers should check.

The short answer

If your buyer is using a mortgage and the lender's appraisal comes in below the contract price, what happens next in Texas depends mostly on two TREC forms. The Third Party Financing Addendum (TREC 40-11) lets the buyer terminate and get the earnest money back if the lender decides the property doesn't meet its underwriting requirements, including the appraisal, as long as the buyer gives notice on or before the 3rd day before the closing date. The optional Addendum Concerning Right to Terminate Due to Lender's Appraisal (TREC 49-1) can change that: the buyer may waive the appraisal termination right, waive it partially above a set value, or get an additional right to terminate below a set value. As a seller, read which boxes were checked before you start negotiating.

This post is general information from the TREC forms. It's not legal advice. Your agent or a real estate attorney can tell you how they apply to your contract.

What TREC 40-11 says about the appraisal

The current Third Party Financing Addendum, TREC 40-11, has been in use since January 3, 2025, according to TREC's form page. Paragraph 2 splits approval of financing into two parts:

  • Buyer Approval (2A) is about the buyer: assets, income and credit. The contract may or may not be subject to it, depending on the box checked.
  • Property Approval (2B) is about the house. If the buyer's lender determines the property doesn't satisfy its underwriting requirements, "including but not limited to appraisal, insurability, and lender required repairs," the buyer may terminate on or before the 3rd day before the Closing Date by giving you notice and a copy of the lender's written statement of the reasons. The earnest money is refunded.

If the buyer doesn't terminate under 2B in time, the form says Property Approval is deemed obtained. Watch that date.

FHA and VA loans work differently

Paragraph 4 of 40-11 covers FHA and VA financing. The buyer isn't obligated to complete the purchase, or to forfeit earnest money, unless the buyer receives a written statement of appraised value of at least the amount written in that paragraph. The buyer can still choose to go ahead regardless of the appraised value. The form also says the 3-day notice requirement in 2B doesn't apply to Paragraph 4.

For VA loans, if the buyer proceeds above the VA's reasonable value, the buyer pays the difference in cash. If the VA's reasonable value is below the sales price, the form says the seller may reduce the price to that value and close at the lower price.

The appraisal addendum below can't be used on these loans: TREC 49-1 is only for contracts that aren't FHA or VA.

What TREC 49-1 can change

The Addendum Concerning Right to Terminate Due to Lender's Appraisal, TREC 49-1, gives three choices. Only one box can be checked:

  1. Waiver. The buyer gives up the right to terminate under 2B if Property Approval fails because of the appraised value. If the lender lowers the loan because of the appraisal, the cash portion of the price goes up by that amount. In plain terms, the buyer covers the gap.
  2. Partial waiver. Same as above, but only if the appraised value is at or above a dollar figure written into the form. Below that figure, the buyer keeps the 2B right.
  3. Additional right to terminate. On top of 2B, the buyer may terminate within a set number of days after the effective date if the lender's appraisal is below a stated value and the buyer delivers a copy of the appraisal to you. The earnest money is refunded.

Notice that the waiver options cover the opinion of value only. Other Property Approval problems, like insurability or lender-required repairs, are still part of 2B.

Seller options when the appraisal comes in low

Nothing in these forms forces a seller to lower the price on a conventional loan. What usually happens is a negotiation, and each choice should be put in writing through an amendment:

  • Hold the price if the buyer has waived the appraisal right and can cover the gap.
  • Meet in the middle: a partial price reduction with the buyer bringing more cash.
  • Lower the price to the appraised value to keep the deal.
  • Question the appraisal through the buyer's lender if you have strong recent sales the appraiser may have missed. Your agent can help assemble them.
  • Let the buyer walk if they terminate in time, and relist.

Pricing to recent sales from the start helps. We've written about pricing your East Texas home to today's market.

Dates to track

If repairs are part of the lender's conditions, our guide to buyer repair requests after inspection explains how agreed repairs are handled.

Bottom line

A low appraisal doesn't automatically end a Texas sale. Under TREC 40-11, a conventional-loan buyer can usually terminate for a failed Property Approval up to three days before closing, unless TREC 49-1 waived or limited that right. FHA and VA loans follow Paragraph 4. Know which boxes are checked, and get any price change into a signed amendment.

Selling in Nacogdoches or Lufkin? Our Nacogdoches and Lufkin seller pages include recent median sale-price figures with their sources.

Thinking about selling? Request a free home value estimate and get your timeline questions answered early.

🏠
On The Market Texas
Free East Texas Home Value Estimates

Ready to find out what your East Texas home is worth? Request a free home value estimate from a local real estate professional — no obligation.

Request My Free Estimate →

More East Texas Real Estate Articles